This article is an evaluation of Christian views about Buddhism based on Paul Williams’ The Unexpected Way: On Converting from Buddhism to Catholicism (2002). Studstill focuses specifically on five Christian claims about Buddhism: (1) Buddhism prevents the recognition of objective reality and objective truth, (2) Buddhism promotes egoism, (3) Buddhism encourages immorality, (4) Buddhism is quite possibly irrational, and (5) Buddhism is excessively pessimistic. Studstill critically examines Williams’ defense of these claims and concludes that each is either false or highly problematic. As a corrective to Williams’ errors about Buddhism, Studstill clarifies Buddhist views regarding suffering and egoism, the transformation of consciousness, the realization of truth, and the cultivation of altruism and compassion.